The “weirdos” (which include Patrick Stewart and other alums) aren’t objecting to the content but to the preachy, heavy-handed delivery. Roddenberry commented on the ridiculousness of racism with two characters hating each other for being the wrong color on the wrong side. The Picard s2 writers had characters walk around present-day LA saying things like, “There’s so much the social injustice!” The complaint about modern Trek is that it tries too hard to be “woke” and not hard enough to be good science fiction.
That’s a potentially valid complaint, I was thinking more of people just complaining that Star Trek is bad just because it’s become too woke and liberal, though. People like my father will just moan, “I don’t know why they have to make it political with this stuff, Star Trek never used to do that.” if he sees an episode with more than one black character in it. There are some real idiots out there.
There are idiots out there, but also a lot of people we assume are idiots because for some reason we want to draw the worst possible conclusion and define them as The Enemy.
The “weirdos” (which include Patrick Stewart and other alums) aren’t objecting to the content but to the preachy, heavy-handed delivery. Roddenberry commented on the ridiculousness of racism with two characters hating each other for being the wrong color on the wrong side. The Picard s2 writers had characters walk around present-day LA saying things like, “There’s so much the social injustice!” The complaint about modern Trek is that it tries too hard to be “woke” and not hard enough to be good science fiction.
It’s so crazy how the difference between “preached” and “commented” is based on your specific opinion of where social progress should have stopped 🤔
As opposed to characters walking around modern day San Francisco discussing environmentalist taking points?
Please. Trek has never been subtle. Anyone accusing Trek of “trying to be too woke” was never paying attention in the first place.
No no no it’s simple see:
Black lady serving on the bridge crew = “social commentary”
Black lady leading the bridge crew = “preachy heavy handed delivery trying too hard to be woke”
That’s a potentially valid complaint, I was thinking more of people just complaining that Star Trek is bad just because it’s become too woke and liberal, though. People like my father will just moan, “I don’t know why they have to make it political with this stuff, Star Trek never used to do that.” if he sees an episode with more than one black character in it. There are some real idiots out there.
There are idiots out there, but also a lot of people we assume are idiots because for some reason we want to draw the worst possible conclusion and define them as The Enemy.
I read that a couple times trying to figure out what was wrong with Morn.